Measuring the impact of a MAP on clients in 2 programs in Ontario- National Homelessness Directorate

Dyanne Semogas, Wendy Muckle, Tomislav Svoboda
The research question that the study will address under the Ontario
Homelessness Directorate, Holistic Program Delivery Approaches, Harm
Reduction is: what are the impacts, benefits and drawbacks of an
integrated health and social service harm reduction delivery approach
on participants? There are three Managed Alcohol Programs in the
country and all located in the Province of Ontario. This allows us the
unique opportunity of pooling data from 2 of the programs in Hamilton
and Ottawa. Through quantitative and qualitative methods the study will
document the impact of the program on clients transiting from the
streets to a managed alcohol environment. In keeping with the shift in
thinking in the mental health field this study is based on a paradigm
of recovery; rather than one of pathology. Participant input into their
health and social service use; their perception of their physical and
mental health status and their experience of living on the streets and
then housed in a managed alcohol environment is beinng studied. To date
health and social service utilization has been documented in Hamilton.
Ottawa is completing Time 2 interviews.
From Nowhere to Somewhere: Profiles of individuals as they move from the streets to a Managed Alcohol Environment, SSHRC
Dyanne Semogas, Helen Kirkpatrick, Jennifer Blythe, Lindsey George, Kristin
Cleverley and Sean Kidd
This narrative study explores the experiences of 20 homeless individuals living
with alcohol dependence as they move from the streets to a managed alcohol environment.
It is one component of a multi-method study to assess the impacts, benefits
and drawbacks of an integrated health and social service harm reduction model.
The narrative component aims to bring to life the stories of those who are stigmatized
for both their addiction and their homelessness. Participants will be interviewed
up to three times over 9 months. The set of 3 interviews is nearing completion.
Analysis is being conducted by different disciplines to increase understanding
of the various stories. This will include a holistic-content perspective and
holistic-form perspective to consider plots and structure from English Literature,
a Geographic perspective to consider issues of space and place, a Psychiatry
perspective to consider the experience of illness, a Nursing perspective to
consider the impact of family, and a Community perspective to consider the experience
of loss and attachment. We have done several presentations at various conferences.
There is a significant student training program involved in this study. PhD
students from McMaster School of Geography Josh Evans and McMaster Department
of English Christina Brooks are involved in the interviews and analysis. A Master�s
Student from York University in Environmental Studies Sarah Sanford was involved
with the initial interviews and has moved PHD studies at the University of Toronto
Community Health. She is also the recipient of a SSHRC Student Award to support
her PhD studies. Undergraduate BScN student Amy Clause, was involved with transcribing
data and has moved on to MScN studies at McMaster University.
Undergraduate students in the BScN program who have participated in their 4L02
Coursework include: Rachel Parkinson, Sherri Polos and Shaguftah Patel.